Book Review: The House Across the Lake by Riley Sager
As I settled into my reading nook with a glass of wine (ironically, given the book’s themes), I couldn’t help but feel a rush of intrigue about The House Across the Lake by Riley Sager. Known for his knack for thrillers that keep you guessing, I was excited to dive into this latest tale of mystery and voyeurism. There’s something particularly captivating about a novel set against the backdrop of a secluded lake—added solitude and suspense create the perfect recipe for an engaging read.
At the heart of this story is Casey Fletcher, a recently widowed actress retreating to her family’s lake house in Vermont. Armed with binoculars and an ever-growing amount of alcohol, Casey’s obsession with the seemingly perfect couple across the lake—Tom and Katherine Royce—quickly spirals into a web of suspicion and danger. While the story sounds compelling on the surface, I found myself grappling with its familiar tropes and predictability.
A Familiar Plot
This brings me to a central theme that reverberated throughout the novel: the façade of perfection. Initially, I enjoyed the visual thrill of Casey’s voyeuristic escapades; it felt like engaging in guilty pleasures akin to watching a soap opera. However, the plot quickly reminded me of a thousand other stories that tread similar ground. The dynamic of the rich husband and glamorous wife often felt well-trod, making it easy to spot where the narrative might head.
I couldn’t help but notice Sager’s writing has matured since his earlier works, which I appreciated. However, some elements felt heavy-handed—like the repetitive mentions of "across the lake" and "water." At times, I felt like I was being reminded of the setting a bit too often, as if Sager feared we might forget we were at a lake.
Character Dynamics
The characters, particularly Casey, occasionally felt like caricatures rather than fully fleshed-out personas. Casey’s casual, almost flippant response to danger sometimes rang false. For instance, when a stranger casually drops by while she’s alone in the woods, she jokes instead of reacting with apprehension. This lack of relatability was jarring and detracted from my immersion in her character.
Another notable aspect was the portrayal of women in distress. Sager seems to venture into themes of toxic relationships and domestic abuse, but his handling can feel unbalanced. For example, the dynamics between Tom and Katherine led to an uncomfortable realization: at times, it felt as if abuse was normalized rather than critically examined.
The Twists and Turns
For those anticipating a shocking twist, let me assure you that Sager delivers… albeit in a way that might feel slightly strained. As I turned the pages, I found myself longing for depth beyond the thrills, and at times, the narrative felt filled with absurdities that pulled me out of the suspense. The grand twist involving possession felt abrupt and jarring, tacking on a supernatural element that felt out of place in a thriller focused on human flaws and secrets.
Ultimately, I finished the book feeling as though I had run a roller coaster that never quite reached a thrilling peak.
Who Will Enjoy This?
Despite my critiques, The House Across the Lake will resonate with Sager’s consistent fanbase—those who enjoy light mystery with a twist without the need for substantial depth. If you appreciate whimsical thrillers that draw on classic cinematic influences (I definitely felt a Rear Window vibe), this might just be your cup of tea.
As for me, I believe Riley Sager is an author with promise; however, I find myself interested in where he will go next. I’ll be hoping for an evolution in plot complexity and character authenticity in his future endeavors. If you’re looking for a quick, thrilling read devoid of heavy themes, then maybe grab a glass of something nice, kick back, and give this one a go.
Discover more about The House Across the Lake on GoodReads >>