Review of Pitcher Perfect (Big Shots, #4) by Tessa Bailey
When the spicy romcom queen herself, Tessa Bailey, drops a new book, my heart races with anticipation—and Pitcher Perfect was no exception. As a long-time fan and frequent flyer in her quirky and romantic world, I dove into this latest installment of the Big Shots series with the same thrill as a kid at the ballpark. With promises of laugh-out-loud moments and charming characters, I couldn’t wait to see how Robbie and Skylar would steal my heart.
If there’s one thing Tessa Bailey excels at, it’s crafting characters who are both endearingly flawed and irresistibly relatable. Skylar, a driven 22-year-old college softball star affectionately dubbed “Rocket,” is a type-A planner with a fierce spunk that made her come alive on the page. Robbie, a rookie hockey player known as “Redbeard,” is the charming reformed playboy whose antics had me giggling and swooning. Their dynamic was like a playful game of cat and mouse, where the banter sparkled with tension and wit.
At its core, Pitcher Perfect is a delightful exploration of family, competitive spirit, and the often hilarious chaos of fake dating. Robbie’s agreement to be Skylar’s pretend boyfriend adds a layer of complexity as they navigate her eccentric family’s wild wilderness games—and their own feelings. The book blends comedic elements with genuine emotional beats, though I did find the pacing at times veering heavily into quick, insta-love territory. As someone who enjoys a gradual build-up in romance, I wished for just a touch more time for their connection to deepen.
Tessa’s writing style is a warm hug, filled with the zany charm that we’ve come to love. The snappy dialogue and vivid descriptions pulled me right into the bustling world of Boston and Rhode Island, while the references to past characters like Burgess, Tallulah, Sig, and Chloe made me feel like I was reconnecting with old friends. One of my favorite quotes perfectly encapsulates Skylar’s humor: “Besides pitch like a Hall of Famer, what are you into?” to which she replies, “Cannibalism.” This cheekiness pulled me right into her character’s spirit!
As usual, Tessa’s penchant for witty repartee and relatable insights kept me both laughing and reflective. Lines like, “I got a speeding ticket on my way back to you,” suggested that love, much like a good game, can sometimes be a wild ride.
Overall, I would heartily recommend Pitcher Perfect to anyone who revels in the chaos of sports romances or enjoys stories where the protagonist refuses to sway easily to charm. The unique blend of spice, comedy, and family antics ensures that there’s something for everyone. As for me, reading this book with my pal Lina made the experience even more memorable; we shared laughs and eye rolls, enjoying our little buddy read adventure together.
In the end, this charming romp through the ups and downs of young love not only entertained me but also reminded me of the joy found in unabashedly embracing life’s quirks—chasing dreams, and maybe a little chaos along the way. So grab your eReader and prepare to be swept off your feet—Robbie and Skylar’s story is worth every page! Pitcher Perfect is set to hit shelves on September 9, and I can’t wait to hear how others will fall in love with it, just like I did.
Discover more about Pitcher Perfect (Big Shots, #4) on GoodReads >>