Review of Everyone Is Lying to You by Jo Piazza: A Thrilling Mirror to Our Social Media Lives
I picked up Everyone Is Lying to You by Jo Piazza with a mix of intrigue and curiosity, sparked by its premise and the current sociocultural landscape where curated Instagram feeds have almost become our reality. As a book blogger, I find myself delving deep into narratives that prompt reflection on our digital personas, and Piazza’s thrilling take on influencer culture speaks directly to that fascination.
The story revolves around Lizzie Matthews, a struggling magazine writer wrestling with the chaos of motherhood and her waning career. When her former best friend, Rebecca “Bex” Sommers—now a seemingly perfect tradwife influencer—invites her to interview her, the everyday reunion quickly spirals into a chilling murder mystery when Bex’s husband, Grayson, is found dead, and Bex disappears. What begins as a straightforward narrative unfolds into a powerful critique of social media’s carefully curated facades, exploring themes of authenticity, ambition, and the dangerous allure of perfection.
Lizzie’s character struck a chord with me. Her evolution from passive observer to determined investigator mirrors our collective obsession with the highlight reels of others’ lives. Piazza’s portrayal of her as an unreliable narrator heightens the tension—where does ambition end and deception begin? This complicated depiction resonated with my own experiences of scrolling through social media, where envy and admiration often collide.
One of the novel’s most poignant aspects is Rebecca’s story, revealing that the influencer life isn’t always as glamorous as it appears. Her descent from a college rebel to a digitally fabricated “Stepford wife” embodies the price of social media validation. It’s a grave reminder of how the pressure to maintain a perfect image can entrap us, echoing the struggles many face in the pursuit of likes and followers.
Piazza’s insider knowledge of the influencer world is evident. Her writing style is sharp and compelling, characterized by short, punchy sentences that mirror the constant flow of content we consume daily. I found myself engrossed, turning pages at lightning speed, often stopping to reflect on particularly biting observations about our online lives, such as when Lizzie’s follower count skyrockets amidst a murder investigation. It’s absurd yet painfully relatable.
While the novel excels in its cultural critique and social commentary, it occasionally stumbles over familiar thriller tropes. Some plot twists feel contrived, with characters withholding information in ways that verge on melodrama. Despite these hiccups, Piazza’s ambition shines through—she tackles heavy themes of exploitation and the interconnected harms of social media with nuance and insight.
In the end, Everyone Is Lying to You is far from perfect, but it’s an important read for anyone grappling with the impacts of digital life. It appeals not only to fans of mystery and thriller genres but also to readers interested in the intersections of culture, identity, and technology.
For me, this book was a chase—not just for the truth behind the murder but for understanding how we interact within our hyperconnected world. It’s a chilling reminder that the lies we tell ourselves about authenticity in our relationships often run deeper than the carefully composed images on our screens. If you’re looking for a gripping read that provokes thought and discussion, Jo Piazza’s latest offering is a must.
Discover more about Everyone Is Lying to You on GoodReads >>