Just Some Stupid Love Story: A Romance That Missed the Mark
I was really looking forward to Just Some Stupid Love Story by Tessa McGraw. With a title that hints at playful irony, I couldn’t resist picking it up, especially with 2024 marked as the year of extraordinary romances. However, after diving into Molly and Seth’s convoluted love story, I found myself wishing I had spent my time elsewhere. Sadly, this marks my sixth consecutive miss in the realm of recent romantic reads.
From the get-go, McGraw plunks us down into the well-trodden grumpy-sunshine trope. However, instead of crafting relatable characters, we’re instead confronted with bitter caricatures. Molly, the supposed grump, feels less like an underdog with quirks and more like a canary in a coal mine, registering every emotional detonation yet managing to evict genuine connection. Her character is ultimately exhausting; one minute she emotionally eviscerates Seth, only to cry and wonder why he pulls away. The emotional whiplash she inflicts on him feels less like relatable conflict and more akin to toxicity masked as romance.
Seth, on the other hand, is an oddly unsettling blend of Stockholm Syndrome and a “golden retriever” vibe. Their interactions, meant to be flirtatious banter, often read as manipulative gaslighting. Instead of an engaging love story, we’re treated to an emotional tug-of-war that left me feeling uncomfortable rather than invested in their relationship. It seemed more an exercise in endurance than romance — and not the thrilling kind.
McGraw’s writing style didn’t help much either. There were numerous moments that called for deeper emotional exploration, yet they felt shockingly superficial. Rather than dive into the messiness of genuine human feelings, the characters lingered in a realm of exaggerated caricatures and soap-opera-level drama. Bold claims about the inability to love or maintain a meaningful relationship, predicated solely on parental divorce, felt trite. When did emotional depth become a mere façade for dysfunction?
One moment in particular made my head spin: Molly’s admission that she writes rom-coms purely for financial gain. This almost felt like an affront to the genre itself! Ultimately, it’s puzzling how readers are supposed to root for someone who openly dismisses the magic that romance can capture. It’s disheartening to witness a genre that thrives on hope being tainted by cynicism.
As for the “hot moments” in the book, they fell flat. What was intended as steamy often veered into cringe-worthy territory. The fade to black scenes and awkward attempts at phone intimacy were more akin to a bad sitcom than a romantic adventure.
While readers looking for “damaged” and “messy” characters might still find some redemption in Just Some Stupid Love Story, I’m left craving authentic romantic narratives that don’t merely glorify toxic behaviors. A richly written romance should resonate beyond the pages, encapsulating a love that feels not just achievable but also desirable.
Ultimately, if you’re searching for true love stories where characters evolve through vulnerability and connection, you might want to pass on this one. But for those who enjoy a good cringe or a fleeting rollercoaster of emotions, perhaps give this a shot. The dismissal of romantic ideals in such cozy settings left me needing more — and I sincerely hope the next title I pick up breaks this disappointing streak!
Discover more about Just Some Stupid Love Story on GoodReads >>