The Roommate Experiment (Funny Feelings #3) – A Personal Reflection
As a long-time fan of quirky romances that blend humor with heartfelt moments, I was excited to dive into "The Roommate Experiment" by the immensely talented and engaging author, L. M. Redmond. There’s something magnetic about a story where hidden feelings and friendships collide, particularly when you’ve been secretly in love with someone for years. Hunter and Dylan’s story promised to be an emotional rollercoaster, and while it delivered some charming moments, it ultimately fell a bit short for me.
At its core, "The Roommate Experiment" explores themes of unrequited love and the complexities of friendship. Hunter has been harboring feelings for Dylan, her best friend’s brother, for eleven long years. The narrative deftly navigates her internal struggles as she fumbles through life, trying to mask her feelings while dealing with the challenges of casual dating. I genuinely appreciated the authenticity of Hunter’s emotions; her crushed fantasies spilled into relatable moments of jealousy, frustration, and hopelessness. Yet, I couldn’t help but feel some of her character’s emotional depth occasionally got overshadowed by the romantic drama surrounding her.
Dylan, on the other hand, started strong but slowly began to irritate me as the story progressed. I found myself caught between wanting to support his growth and rolling my eyes at his indecisiveness. There’s a fine line between being cautious and being a coward, and unfortunately, he crossed it too often for my liking. While his character had potential, I felt that key moments—especially the breakup scene—could have had a more significant impact. It was frustrating to see a pivotal arc fumbled, diminishing the overall momentum of the romance.
The writing style, however, was one of the book’s bright spots. Redmond’s light, humorous approach to serious topics like dyslexia and endometriosis made the narrative feel approachable and engaging. Hunter’s clumsy yet genuine moments often had me chuckling out loud. And while the intimacy shifted towards the latter part of the book, with some hinting at spicy moments, it felt slightly forced. A little less emphasis on the fade-to-black encounters could have actually allowed for deeper emotional connections elsewhere.
I can’t help but mention that I read "If the Ring Fits" beforehand, and I highly recommend others do the same if they wish to enhance their reading experience. It adds context to Hunter and Dylan’s relationship, making this reunion feel less jarring and more enjoyable. Revisiting scenes from different perspectives was quite intriguing—a lovely narrative experiment!
In conclusion, The Roommate Experiment is a lighthearted read perfect for those who enjoy steady-paced romances that toy with feelings and friendships. Though it didn’t quite capture my heart like Redmond’s previous works—Adrian is still my all-time favorite—I can see fans of the series enjoying it immensely. If you’re looking for a romance that balances humor and heartfelt moments, this might just be your next cozy read. I’m looking forward to exploring more of L. M. Redmond’s future stories, even if this one didn’t hit all the right notes for me.
Thank you to Rachel’s Random Resources and Boldwood Books for providing the eARC. This review is entirely based on my honest feelings about the book! #NetGalley
Discover more about The Roommate Experiment (Funny Feelings #3) on GoodReads >>