Review of The Unraveling of Julia by Lisa Scottoline
From the moment I spotted The Unraveling of Julia on my shelves, I knew it would be a journey worth taking. Lisa Scottoline has always been one of my go-to thriller authors—her ability to blend tension and emotion keeps me on the edge of my seat every time I settle into my favorite couch. This novel, however, intrigued me even more with its unique spin on thriller and women’s fiction, set against the magical backdrop of Tuscany. As an astrology enthusiast (Aries rising, Scorpio sun, Sagittarius moon), I couldn’t resist the allure of a storyline that intertwines the stars with the art of storytelling.
The plot revolves around Julie Pritzker, who finds herself caught in a web of trauma and mystery after witnessing her husband’s brutal murder. The stakes are high: what drives this man to sacrifice himself for her? Anchored in fear and isolation, Julie’s life takes a dramatic turn when she receives a letter claiming she’s inherited a crumbling villa in Italy from a woman named Emilia Rossi. Could this mysterious figure be her biological grandmother? The mystery unfolds as she travels to Tuscany, only to encounter hostility from the locals and an eerie connection to her potential ancestry.
What kept me glued to the pages were the two intertwining mysteries—what happened in the villa and the truth behind Julie’s biological family. Though some of the paranormal twists felt a bit over-the-top, the pacing was masterfully heart-thumping, compelling me to turn page after page. The writing captured the essence of a truly haunting tale, though there were moments when I found myself shaking my head at the characters’ acceptance of the paranormal. Perhaps it’s a cultural lens; in a different setting, Julie might have been perceived as losing her mind. Yet, the artistic and creative spirit of Italy allows for a richer interpretation of the unexplained.
The characters are robust and thoughtfully crafted, especially Julie and the charming librarian, Gianluca. While the romantic undertones had hints of a Hallmark vibe—which wasn’t my favorite aspect—the chemistry and camaraderie were nevertheless delightful. There were times when I rolled my eyes at certain plot developments, but I appreciated Scottoline’s penchant for taking risks to breathe life into her narrative.
Overall, this book was a riveting experience for me. I’m rounding up my 3.5-star rating to 4 stars, primarily because of its unique concept, engaging mysteries, and the individuality of its characters, even if I don’t always see eye to eye with my fellow Cancer women! I wholeheartedly recommend The Unraveling of Julia to anyone in search of a captivating read that will echo long after you’ve turned the last page, perhaps even prompting you to book a ticket to Italy along the way.
A special thanks to NetGalley and Grand Central Publishing for providing me with a digital reviewer copy. If you’re intrigued by a blend of paranormal mystery and emotional depth, you’ll want to dive into Julia’s story—it might just unravel your own sense of wonder.
Feel free to follow my musings on books, movies, and, of course, astrology over on Medium, Instagram, Facebook, or Twitter! Happy reading!