Review of Thrown for a Loop (New York Legends, #1) by Sarina Bowen
You know how some books feel like a warm hug on a chilly day? That’s the vibe I was hoping for with Thrown for a Loop. Having dipped my toes into both new and established writers this year, I finally picked up a Sarina Bowen book—a name I’ve heard buzzing around for ages due to her collaborations with Elle Kennedy. Hockey romances are my absolute comfort zone, and while Kennedy sets that gold standard, Bowen intrigued me enough to take the plunge. So, here I am, sharing my thoughts as I unwrapped this delightful offering.
Thrown for a Loop revolves around Chase Merritt, a star hockey player grappling with a troubled past, and Zoe Carson, an ambitious figure skater turned coach. Their history begins at a summer camp ten years prior, and the unfortunate decisions of youth drive a wedge between them, setting the stage for a second-chance romance. The concept had me hooked: nostalgia, unresolved tension, and the backdrop of shared sports. Not to mention, the promise of a "PR redemption story" featuring a lot of emotional fireworks!
Overall, it was a charming read laden with cute moments and plenty of potential. Zoe stands tall as a strong, independent character, and Chase balances swagger with vulnerability—both traits I enjoyed. The sports elements, especially the intricate descriptions of hockey and figure skating, certainly shone, showcasing Zoe’s expertise which I found engaging.
Yet, the narrative structure stumbled a bit. The alternating perspectives sometimes offered dizzying whiplash rather than immersion. The shifts—from a layered third-person perspective on Chase’s flashbacks to Zoe’s first-person present—felt jarring, blocking deeper connections to the characters. I was hoping that as I devoured the book, I’d be enveloped in their past, yet I found myself skimming over flashbacks due to diminishing interest.
And then there’s the emotional depth—or lack thereof. While there are glimpses of trauma and regret, Bowen doesn’t dive deeply enough into the water. The anticipation of that big emotional reveal? A tad anticlimactic. When everything wrapped up, the resolution didn’t quite land the punch I yearned for. The chemistry? Cute but not sizzling—less “on fire” and more “warm glow” if you catch my drift. I’m all for a sweet banter, but heart-thumping tension and spice also keep me entranced, and this story skimmed the surface.
That said, the characters who lingered in my mind are secondary. Zoe’s best friend Darcy and Chase’s teammate Eric stood out with personalities bursting off the page, making me even more eager for their stories in future installments. Honestly, by the end of this book, I found myself more curious about them than Zoe and Chase’s romance.
Finally, I couldn’t quite buy into Chase’s arc—his transition from a brooding athlete to a light-hearted, almost golden-retriever-like character felt more like an inconsistency than growth. That caught me off guard and disrupted my connection to him.
In summation, Thrown for a Loop is a sweet, easy read—perfect for anyone searching for light, sporty escapism. It may not tug at the heartstrings in the way I hoped, but it’s charming enough to warrant a read—especially if you enjoy a nostalgic second-chance setup. While this particular trip on the ice didn’t fully satisfy my cravings, I’m curious about the journey ahead with Bowen. Here’s to hoping I’m swept off my feet with Darcy and Eric’s story next! If you’re looking for something comforting and low on angst, this one might just be what you need. Happy reading!
Discover more about Thrown for a Loop (New York Legends, #1) on GoodReads >>